Skip to main content

Please note that the RTPI’s offices will be closed from the afternoon of Monday 23 December and will re-open on Thursday 2 January 2025.

Close Menu Open Menu

Sir Peter Hall Award for Research Excellence Winner

The whittling away of wonderful ideas: post-consent and the diminution of design quality

Hannah Hickman

(The University of the West of England)

  Co-authored by:

Nick Croft (The University of the West of England)

Dr Hooman Foroughmand-Araabi (The University of the West of England)

Dr Katie McClymont (The University of the West of England)

Adam Sheppard (The University of the West of England)

 

Research Description

This project explored the under-researched and poorly-understood area of post-consent - the journey of a development from the point of permission through to delivery and on-going management. In particular: it evidenced a worrying decline in design quality occurring at this point;
it identified some of the causes; and, considered what local authorities might do to address this decline. More broadly, it encourages planning to be understood as a more enduring process and not one which finishes at the point of permission. With major planning reform on the agenda in England, and a signalled intent to further front-load decision making, understanding what happens post-permission is more, rather than less, critical.

Full Entry Title

Hickman, H., Croft, N., Foroughmand Araabi, H., McClymont, K., & Sheppard, A. (2021). The whittling away of wonderful ideas: post-consent and the diminution of design quality. West of England Combined Authority

The Judges Said...

Presented in plain language, the research is a clear exposition of the need to ensure the integrity of the planning system whilst designing robust post consent processes that are flexible in the face of changed circumstances, allowing consented features of a scheme to change where necessary.  The judges agreed that ‘The whittling away of wonderful ideas’ is a valuable and timely piece of work, which has emerged from a fruitful dialogue between practice and academia.